Chapter 12: The Truth CJ Could Not Risk

Image Credit: Envato.com

Chapter 11 Recap

St. Patrick’s Day turns campus into the exact kind of crowd CJ understands best: loud, distracted, and ready to believe whatever appears on a screen first. Jamie, Riley, and Alex try to keep the day public and careful, but when Alex helps a student in distress, a clip goes online almost immediately. The timing is too fast to feel accidental. By the end of the day, Jamie realizes someone was ready to frame the moment before the crowd even understood what was happening.

Read Chapter 11 of the series.

Chapter 12

By the second week of March, Jamie had stopped measuring time by classes.

She measured it by screenshots, dates, and timestamps. She measured it by when a post appeared, when it was deleted, and when it resurfaced in another group chat with different wording and the same damage. She measured it by the growing note on her phone, where every incident now lived in neat lines that made the whole thing look almost reasonable, which was its own kind of horror.

Outside, campus kept pretending spring was close. Snowbanks had shrunk into grey ridges along the sidewalks, and wet patches spread across the paths where the sun managed to break through. Students moved faster now, jackets unzipped, faces turned toward the light as if the term might soften if they wanted it badly enough.

Nothing about the story felt softer.

Jamie sat at a corner table in Stauffer with Riley across from her and Alex beside her. The three of them were bent over phones, printed screenshots, and a yellow legal pad Riley had stolen from somewhere respectable.

It looked less like a study session and more like a small investigation.

That was exactly what it was.

Riley tapped the top of the legal pad. “Start at the beginning again.”

Jamie rubbed her eyes. “We have done this three times.”

“Yes,” Riley said. “And each time it gets clearer.”

Alex said nothing. He had become quieter in these sessions, not defensive and not withdrawn, but careful. Jamie had noticed the difference. Alex no longer interrupted when Riley pushed. Alex no longer tried to soften facts before they landed. He looked like someone finally understanding that honesty did not stop being honesty just because it hurt.

Jamie exhaled and looked down at the page.

At the top, Riley had written three words in large block letters.

WHO BENEFITS MOST

That question had changed everything.

For weeks, Jamie had been asking why CJ kept targeting her. Why CJ kept circling Alex. Why every moment of confusion seemed to become sharper the second his name got near it.

Now the question was colder and better.

What did CJ need to protect?

Jamie picked up a screenshot from the growing pile. It was the old group chat message Riley had been sent after St. Patrick’s Day.

Alex has the vial. Watch what he does with it.

Jamie looked at the timestamp again.

Then Jamie looked at another screenshot, one Riley had dug out from a private message thread two nights earlier. This one showed CJ pushing the same line after Hawthorne, less directly but with the same effect.

I am not saying it was him. I am just saying people should ask why he was there.

Jamie set the screenshots side by side.

“Same move,” Jamie said quietly.

Riley nodded. “He does not accuse. He frames.”

Alex looked down at the page, jaw tight. “He lets other people finish the sentence.”

Jamie turned to Alex. “Why did you never say that before?”

Alex met her eyes. He did not look away.

“Because I thought if I ignored him, he would stay small,” Alex said. “I thought naming him would make him bigger.”

Riley made a soft sound that was not quite a laugh. “That strategy has aged terribly.”

Alex accepted the hit without flinching. “Yes.”

Jamie looked back at the paper. Her pulse had settled into something steadier over the past few days. She was not calm exactly, but she was focused. Fear still lived under everything, but it no longer ran the room.

That was one of the few good things counselling had already started to give her.

It had not given her relief.

It had given her language.

At the intake appointment, the therapist had not acted impressed by the screenshots or overly alarmed by the pattern. The therapist had simply named what Jamie was dealing with.

Patterned harassment. Social manipulation. Coercive control through public pressure.

The words gave Jamie a straighter posture and a clearer sense of what she was facing.

The problem had not become smaller once Jamie could name it. It had simply become harder to ignore.

Riley slid another screenshot toward the center of the table. “Look at this one again.”

Jamie frowned. It was from a St. Patrick’s repost thread. Most of the comments were blurry or useless, but one line had been highlighted in yellow.

History repeats when people do not learn who to trust.

No name. No profile photo. Just a burner account that had disappeared within an hour.

Alex leaned in. “That sounds like him.”

“It does,” Jamie said. “But that still is not motive.”

Riley tapped the legal pad. “Then stop looking at the posts and start looking at the night itself.”

Jamie went still.

The night itself.

Not Hawthorne as rumor. Hawthorne as sequence.

Alex saw the shift in Jamie’s face. “What?”

Jamie looked up slowly. “We keep treating CJ like he attached himself to the fallout.”

Riley’s eyes narrowed. “And?”

“And what if he needed the fallout,” Jamie said.

Silence settled over the table.

Alex sat back slightly. The movement was small, but Jamie caught it.

“What are you thinking?” Riley asked.

Jamie looked at the notes, then at Alex.

“If CJ only liked attention, he could have picked any scandal,” Jamie said. “Any party. Any rumor. Any relationship mess. But he keeps returning to Hawthorne. He keeps returning to the vial. He keeps returning to you.”

Alex’s face tightened.

Jamie continued, slower now, shaping the thought as she spoke. “That means Hawthorne gave him something. A chance to build a story, yes. But maybe also a reason.”

Riley leaned back in her chair, arms crossed. “You think he was protecting someone.”

Jamie held Riley’s gaze. “Or himself.”

The words landed hard enough that even the silence afterward felt different.

Alex looked down at the table. His fingers had curled around the edge of his notebook so tightly his knuckles had gone pale.

Jamie noticed.

“Tell me what you are not saying,” Jamie said.

Alex closed his eyes briefly, then opened them.

“There is someone you have not asked enough about,” Alex said quietly.

Riley’s posture sharpened immediately. “Who?”

Alex swallowed. “Evan Mercer.”

The name tugged at something half-buried in Jamie’s memory. She could not place him at first, but then fragments returned. A residence rumor from last year. A face in the background of a photo she had scrolled past without caring. A name that had floated briefly through campus talk and then vanished, which now felt meaningful in its own way.

“Who is Evan Mercer?” Jamie asked.

Alex looked at Jamie, then at Riley, as if checking whether he still had the right to speak into the room.

“He lived in Hawthorne last year,” Alex said. “He knew CJ. Not best friends, but close enough. Same circles. Same parties. Same people around them.”

Riley’s voice stayed flat. “And?”

Alex’s jaw tightened. “The medication in the vial was his.”

Jamie felt the air change.

The library stayed the same around them. Pages turning. Chairs scraping softly against the floor. A student coughing somewhere near the stacks.

But at the table, everything shifted.

Jamie stared at Alex. “You knew.”

“Yes.”

The word came out thin but steady.

Jamie’s throat tightened. “You let me keep circling this, and you knew the vial belonged to someone connected to CJ.”

Alex did not defend himself immediately, which almost made it worse.

Finally Alex said, “I did not know how much CJ was tied into it. Not then. Not fully. I knew Evan panicked. I knew Evan shoved the vial at me and told me to get rid of it. I knew I was stupid enough to think I could protect him.”

Riley’s expression hardened into something almost clinical. “And now?”

Alex exhaled slowly. “Now I think protecting Evan may have protected CJ too.”

Jamie sat back.

It was not relief or vindication. It was the cold sensation of a door opening inward.

“Why would Evan matter that much?” Jamie asked.

Alex answered carefully. “Because Evan had something to lose. Family reputation. Residence position. Academic standing. His name getting attached to the incident would have changed things for him.”

Riley said, “And CJ?”

Alex’s eyes went distant for a second, as if he were forcing old details into place. “CJ always stayed near the people with the most to lose. That is how he made himself useful.”

Jamie felt that in her chest like a click.

Useful.

CJ was not acting randomly, and he was not driven only by obsession. He had made himself useful.

Jamie leaned forward. “Did Evan ask you directly to stay quiet?”

“Yes.”

“Did CJ know?”

Alex looked at the screenshots, then at Jamie. “I cannot prove it. But I think so.”

Riley reached for the legal pad and wrote Evan Mercer’s name in capital letters, then circled it once. Underneath, Riley wrote CJ.

Jamie watched the lines form between the names like the outline of something she should have seen sooner.

“Did Mara know?” Jamie asked.

Alex nodded once. “Some of it.”

Riley looked up. “Then we need Mara.”

Alex’s mouth tightened. “She is not going to love that.”

Riley’s voice turned dry. “Nobody here seems to enjoy accountability. It has been exhausting.”

Jamie almost smiled, but her chest still felt too tight.

Mara had not answered Jamie’s last message. Then again, Jamie had not sent one in over a week. The midnight at Hawthorne chapter had left all three of them bruised in different ways.

Still, if Mara knew more, Jamie was done pretending that silence was neutral.

Jamie picked up her phone.

Her thumb hovered over Mara’s name.

Before Jamie could talk herself out of it, she typed:

I need the truth about Evan Mercer. Not rumor. Not protection. The truth.

Jamie hit send.

For a second, nobody spoke.

Then Riley reached for her own coffee and said, “Good.”

Alex looked at Jamie. “You think she will answer?”

Jamie stared at the message thread. “She might not.”

Alex nodded. “That is fair.”

Jamie looked up sharply. “You do not get to use that phrase every time things become inconvenient.”

Alex blinked, then gave a tired half-smile that vanished almost as fast as it appeared. “Noted.”

The phone buzzed so quickly all three of them looked down at once.

Mara’s reply was only four words.

Meet me. Today. Alone.

Riley let out a small, humorless laugh. “Absolutely not.”

Jamie was already typing.

No. Public. Riley comes.

This time the response took longer.

When it came, it was colder.

Then Alex does not.

Jamie stared at the screen.

Alex looked away first.

That told Jamie more than any explanation could have.

“She hates you today?” Riley asked without sympathy.

Alex gave a low breath that might have been a laugh in another life. “Reasonable.”

Jamie typed back.

Library café. One hour. Riley comes.

Mara’s answer was immediate.

Fine. Bring your notes.

Jamie put the phone down.

Riley raised an eyebrow. “Bring your notes?”

“Which means she knows I have been keeping them,” Jamie said.

Alex’s face tightened. “That sounds like Mara.”

Jamie stood up too fast. Her chair scraped against the floor, drawing one annoyed glance from a student nearby.

Jamie steadied herself.

Riley stood too. “You okay?”

Jamie nodded. “Yes.”

That was not entirely true, but it was close enough to function.

The hour before the meeting passed slowly enough to feel deliberate.

Jamie did not go to class. Riley did not either. Alex walked with them as far as the café entrance and then stopped, exactly where he had been told to stop.

Jamie turned to Alex. “If you remember anything else, do not wait until it becomes dramatic.”

Alex’s face shifted, shame and effort crossing through the same expression. “I will text you.”

Jamie held his gaze for a beat. “Good.”

For a second, Alex looked as if he wanted to say something else. His hand moved slightly against his coat, the same small almost-gesture Jamie had seen after St. Patrick’s Day. He was not reaching. He was only wanting to.

Then Alex let it go.

Jamie hated that she noticed.

Jamie hated, too, that part of her wanted Alex to get it right.

Riley touched Jamie’s elbow lightly. “Come on.”

The café smelled like overheated milk and wet coats. Afternoon light pressed weakly against the windows. Students sat with laptops open, pretending they were doing work while watching everything that looked more interesting than their screens.

Mara was already there.

Mara sat at a corner table with a tea gone untouched and a dark coat folded over the chair beside her. Her red hair was pulled back today, which made Mara look sharper, less untidy, and less like a person caught in her own history. She looked more like someone choosing every word before it left her mouth.

Mara’s gaze landed on Jamie first.

Then Riley.

Then the space behind them, checking.

“No Alex,” Mara said.

“No Alex,” Jamie replied.

Mara’s eyes dropped to the folder in Jamie’s hand. “You really did make notes.”

Jamie sat down across from Mara. Riley took the chair beside Jamie without asking permission.

“Yes,” Jamie said. “You should try it. It makes lies harder to keep straight.”

Mara’s mouth twitched once. It might have been irritation. It might have been respect.

“Fine,” Mara said. “What do you want?”

Jamie slid the screenshots onto the table between them. Hawthorne. The vial. CJ’s posts. The St. Patrick’s clip. The Valentine delivery details.

Then Jamie said the name.

“Evan Mercer.”

For the first time since Jamie had sat down, Mara’s composure cracked.

Only slightly.

But Jamie saw it.

So did Riley.

Mara looked at the screenshots, then back at Jamie. “Alex told you.”

“He told me enough,” Jamie said. “I want the rest.”

Mara sat back slowly. Her fingers tightened around the paper cup before she released it.

“Evan was there that night,” Mara said at last. “He was more than there. He was at the center of the panic before anybody understood it was panic.”

Jamie stayed quiet.

Mara continued, voice low and controlled. “He was using medication that was not prescribed to him. He was careless about it. CJ knew. Not because Evan trusted him. Because CJ liked collecting leverage.”

Riley’s expression darkened. “So CJ had something on him.”

Mara nodded once. “Yes.”

Jamie’s pulse started to climb. “And when the student got sick?”

Mara looked down at the table. “Everything moved too fast. People were scared. Evan panicked. Alex tried to help. CJ understood the situation faster than anyone else for one reason.”

Jamie’s throat tightened. “What reason?”

Mara lifted her eyes.

“Because CJ already knew what Evan had brought.”

Jamie froze.

Riley’s voice came out flat and sharp. “You are saying CJ knew there was a vial in the room before the panic even started.”

“Yes,” Mara said.

The word sat there like a blade.

Jamie felt heat and cold collide under her skin.

“Then why did Alex take the fall?” Jamie asked.

Mara’s laugh held no humor. “Because Alex made it easy.”

Jamie flinched.

Mara saw it and softened only a fraction. “It was not because Alex deserved it. It was because he stepped in. It was because he touched the evidence. It was because he tried to protect the wrong person at the worst possible moment. CJ understood immediately that Alex was a better villain than Evan.”

Riley said, “Why?”

Mara answered without pause. “Because people already believed Alex was the kind of person who inserted himself into things. Helpful. Intense. Too involved. That makes for a beautiful scapegoat.”

Jamie’s chest tightened painfully.

Not because Mara was wrong.

Because Mara was precise.

Jamie looked at the screenshots again. CJ’s wording. CJ’s timing. CJ’s insistence on asking questions that pointed in only one direction.

“Why keep it going now?” Jamie asked. “Why not leave it buried?”

Mara’s gaze held hers. “Because you are changing the story.”

Jamie swallowed. “By being with Alex?”

“Yes.”

The simplicity of it made Jamie angry.

Mara went on. “As long as Alex stays the guy everyone half-remembers as risky, CJ gets to stay what he prefers being. Useful. Informed. Untouched. But once people start looking again, once Alex stops being a cautionary tale and starts becoming a person, the old story cracks.”

Riley leaned in. “And Evan?”

Mara’s expression hardened. “Evan graduated and disappeared into a job his family helped arrange. CJ stayed.”

Jamie stared at Mara.

Of course he did.

Of course the one person who thrived on campus memory and social gravity stayed where the narrative still lived.

Jamie’s voice dropped. “So CJ did not only protect Evan. He protected the version of himself that Hawthorne created.”

Mara nodded slowly. “Yes.”

Something in Jamie went still.

It was not relief.

It was the kind of clarity that left no room for fantasy.

CJ had not pursued her because he wanted romance.

CJ had not attacked Alex because he was jealous.

At least, that was not the whole story.

CJ needed control because control kept his own fingerprints off the version of events that had given him power.

Jamie looked at Mara. “Do you have proof?”

Mara hesitated.

That hesitation was enough.

Riley’s voice stayed calm. “You do.”

Mara reached into her bag and pulled out a folded page, worn at the creases from being opened and closed too many times.

Mara slid it across the table.

“It is a screenshot,” Mara said. “From last year. I kept it because I knew one day I might need to remember exactly what he sounded like.”

Jamie unfolded it carefully.

It was a message thread.

CJ’s name sat at the top.

The highlighted line waited in the middle like it had been saved for this moment.

Do not let Evan answer anything. Push Alex’s name. He touched it.

Jamie stopped breathing.

Riley went very still.

Mara’s voice came from farther away than it should have. “That was sent before campus security even finished clearing the building.”

Jamie read the line again.

Then again.

There it was.

Not implication. Not mood. Not timing.

Instruction.

Push Alex’s name.

Jamie had imagined proof before, but holding it felt different. Proof did not calm her. It made everything sharper.

Jamie’s hands shook.

Riley took the page gently before it could slip from Jamie’s fingers. “Do you have the original?”

Mara nodded. “Yes.”

“Will you send it?”

Mara looked at Jamie, not Riley. “If Jamie understands what happens next.”

Jamie forced herself to speak. “What happens next?”

Mara held Jamie’s gaze. “Once this moves beyond rumor, CJ stops playing harmless.”

Jamie felt the warning land, old and familiar.

For the first time in weeks, it did not make Jamie smaller.

It made Jamie angry.

“He already stopped,” Jamie said quietly. “He just assumed I had not noticed.”

Mara looked at Jamie for a long moment.

Then Mara nodded.

For the first time, it did not look like surrender.

It looked like agreement.

Riley slipped the screenshot into the folder and zipped it shut. “We make copies.”

Mara stood, gathering her coat. “Do that.”

Jamie looked up. “You are leaving?”

Mara’s mouth tightened. “I gave you what I have. I am not staying to watch this become a strategy meeting.”

“That is exactly what this is,” Riley said.

“Yes,” Mara replied. “And CJ is very good at strategy.”

Mara pulled her coat on, then paused.

When Mara spoke again, her voice was quieter.

“Alex was reckless,” Mara said. “But Alex was not the one CJ needed protected from.”

Then Mara left.

Jamie sat still even after the door shut behind her.

The café noise returned slowly, and for a few seconds Jamie had to work to separate it from her own thoughts.

Riley exhaled first. “Well.”

Jamie looked at Riley. “He told someone to push Alex’s name.”

“Yes.”

“That means he knew exactly what he was doing.”

“Yes.”

Jamie looked down at the folder in Riley’s hand.

All this time, CJ had felt slippery because he was smart enough never to stand in the center of the mess.

Now Jamie could finally see the shape of it.

CJ did not only survive chaos.

CJ directed blame through it.

Her phone buzzed.

Alex.

Jamie stared at the screen for half a second, then answered.

“What happened?” Alex asked immediately.

Jamie looked at Riley once, then back at the rain-smudged window.

Her voice came out calm.

“CJ knew about the vial before the panic,” Jamie said. “And I have proof that CJ told someone to push your name.”

Silence.

Then Alex said, very quietly, “I knew it. I never had proof, only the feeling that he was always one step too ready.”

Jamie closed her eyes.

It was not relief or vindication.

It was something worse.

Because if Alex had known it in his bones all along, then CJ had not only been shaping the story around them.

CJ had been living inside it for a year.

Jamie opened her eyes and looked out at campus, at students crossing the path with backpacks and coffees and no idea how carefully some stories had been built for them.

“Alex,” Jamie said.

“Yes?”

Jamie’s hand tightened around the edge of the table.

“We are done letting him tell this story first.”

Cliffhanger

CJ did not just exploit Hawthorne. CJ instructed people to push Alex’s name before the truth could settle. If Jamie has proof now, how far will CJ go to protect the lie that built his power?